6

It is less than a year since Carlsen defending his title against Nepomniatchi by the crushing score of 7½-3½. At the time he publicly doubted if he would defend again. According to The Guardian he said:

“It’s been clear to me for most of the year that this world championship should be the last, ... It doesn’t mean as much any more as it once did. I haven’t felt that the positive outweighs the negative. ... For those who expect me to play the world championship next time, the chance that they will be disappointed is very great.”

The article continues:

The 31-year-old said the only thing likely to persuade him to keep defending his title would be if his next opponent was the brilliant 18‑year‑old Alireza Firouzja, who recently broke Carlsen’s record as the youngest 2800-rated player and is now ranked world No 2.

Well, the challenge from Firouzja fizzled out and Nepo has won through again to play the World Championship match. Unless Carlsen has changed his mind, and there is a lot of money to be won even by the loser of such a match, then he will pull out leaving Nepo and Ding to play for the title.

Apart from Fischer, who declined to defend his title against Karpov in 1975, has any other champion expressed public doubts about a defence ahead of such a match?

5
  • 1
    Kasparov didn't defend his title under FIDE and created his own organization, PCA.
    – Akavall
    Jul 8 at 15:23
  • Bobby Fischer was the first not to defend, I believe. Jul 8 at 16:01
  • 2
    @RewanDemontay Actually Alekhine also failed to defend for the excellent reason that he was dead.
    – Brian Towers
    Jul 8 at 16:30
  • 2
    The list would become even longer if we include instances where the defender heaped unreasonable conditions on the challenger to delay matters. Jul 8 at 19:00
  • 1
    @BrianTowers While a morbid technicality, I think we can brush it aside an irreleveant. Jul 8 at 20:05

4 Answers 4

5

Emanual Lasker attempted to not defend his title to avoid playing Capablanca. Capablanca was clearly superior by 1920. Lasker even tried to declare Capablanca the champion without playing.

4

According to this tweet from Carlsen's coach, Peter Heine Nielsen, the answer is "Yes".

When you try to relax by reading a good book on chess history, but it starts like this:

enter image description here

Peter Heine Nielsen gives the source for this as the book Petrosian Year by Year: Volume II (1963-1984) by Tibor Karolyi and Tigran Gyozalyan.

Of course Botvinnik did decide, in the end, to play and lost to Petrosian.

4

Nathaniel Green has written an excellent article, World Champions Who Gave Up The Crown, for Chess.com which comprehensively answers the question. I'll try and summarise.

Garry Kasparov (1993)

Kasparov dropped out of FIDE's championship and started his own via the PCA.

Anatoly Karpov (1999)

This was completely new to me. I hadn't realised that FIDE had made such a dog's breakfast of the world championship that Karpov at a certain stage just withdrew. Here's the explanation from the article:

FIDE almost immediately started messing with the world championship format. In 1996, Karpov was seeded into the semifinal of a 13-player match tournament and defeated GMs Boris Gelfand and Gata Kamsky to keep his title. Karpov's 1998 defense was even less traditional. There was a year less to wait and the Candidates process involved a 97-player super knockout tournament, although Karpov was in the final this time.

GM Viswanathan Anand won the knockout and then had to start playing Karpov less than a week later in a six-game match. Karpov won in rapid tiebreaks. One of his easier championship paths, however, was going to have to be succeeded by his most difficult yet.

The very next year, that super knockout tournament was to be the world championship itself, and Karpov was only to get a first-round bye like several other top players of the time. Karpov didn't agree to being the first champion to have to defend his title this way, so he simply didn't play.

Bobby Fischer (1975)

Of course, we all know Fischer declined to play Karpov in 1975.

Mikhail Botvinnik (1966)

Not quite the same thing. Botvinnik lost the title (for the 3rd and final time) and then declined to take his allotted place in the candidates. FIDE changed the rules, depriving the beaten champion of the right to an immediate replay. As Green puts it:

[Botvinnik], like Carlsen, was unhappy with the world championship process and thus simply stopped participating.

Alexander Alekhine (1946)

War and then death resulted in Alekhine losing the title. He was due to play Botvinnik but died before he got the chance. As the article notes:

Alexander Alekhine didn't exactly give up the title; he died while holding it. That makes it pretty hard to compare his situation to anyone else's, let alone Carlsen's.
...
Just as World War I wiped out a match between Lasker and Akiba Rubinstein, World War II prevented Alekhine and Paul Keres from playing for the title. This time Capablanca's role as the postwar challenger was filled by Mikhail Botvinnik. But, while trying to arrange a match with him, Alekhine was gone, less than a year after the war ended.

Emanuel Lasker (1921)

According to the article:

Emanuel Lasker was the first world champion to express disdain for the title and show, in a public way, that not everyone enjoys occupying the position.
...
Negotiations for the first world championship after the war, between Lasker and Jose Capablanca, grew as strained and bitter as store-brand plain Greek yogurt.

It reached the point where Lasker announced he was resigning his title and giving it to Capablanca. He would still play the match, just as the challenger. Nevertheless, he did, like Carlsen, want to give up the title.

1

No, although there were close cases:

  • Kasparov, then world number 1, did not play in the FIDE World Chess Championship 2005.
  • Leonardo Ljubičić, former world correspondence chess champion, was invited to but did not play in the ICCF World Championship 31 Final. He said it was because the draw rate was so high that it was pointless (personal correspondence).

Neither of them were world champions at the time of the championship, however.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.