I can't see the difference between a waiting move and zugzwang.
-
2Very Closely Related: What is zugzwang in chess?– SecretAgentManNov 29 '21 at 14:32
-
Did you mean to say zugwang here, or zwischenzug?– Noah SnyderNov 30 '21 at 2:08
-
Maybe the translation of the german word "Zugzwang" helps to see the difference? In games, it refers to the general rule of being compelled ("gezwungen sein", noun: "Zwang") to make a move ("ziehen" in this context, noun: "Zug") when it is your turn -- skipping is not an option allowed by the rules of the game. From that point of view, you are always in Zugzwang when you play chess and it is your turn. Having said that, the word comes up mostly when moving weakens your position: "Can I skip my turn?"/"Kann ich passen?" -- "No, the rules compel you to make a move"/"Nein, es herrscht Zugzwang!"– orithenaNov 30 '21 at 15:03
-
1It would have helped if you had written what you think these terms mean.– Carsten SNov 30 '21 at 17:34
Add a comment
|
Zugzwang is when one side would like to "pass" but cannot. With a waiting move, you essentially do "pass". A waiting move could lead to zugzwang if one side has the ability to play them and the other does not, but this is by no means necessary.
An opponent might have their own waiting moves (in which case the game could be drawn by repetition unless one side decides to do something meaningful) or they might have a different evaluation of the position and decide to simply proceed with their plan.
For example, one side might play a waiting move to see which side the opponent castles on, but the opponent may well think that the benefits of castling right then outweigh the drawbacks of giving the first player that information.
A waiting move is a move to wait and see what your opponent will do.
If you are in zugzwang then all moves worsen your position.
-
3Zugzwang is not having only bad moves but especially if making a move worsens your position– MinotNov 29 '21 at 12:29
-
1"If you are in zugzwang then you have only bad moves" is correct but incomplete; I don't think it deserves a downvote. Nov 29 '21 at 14:13
-
2@MichaelWest - I understand where you're coming from, but at least in my mind there's a difference. To me, a "bad move" (in the way I think people usually mean that) is a mistake - an error. Whereas, in zugzwang, there's no error - it's just that there aren't any moves available (at all) that aren't harmful to your position. There's no "error" in that case - it's just that there aren't any decent choices available. Nov 29 '21 at 18:09
-
1
-
2The new wording is missing the word "only." Or, better yet: "all moves worsen your position." Nov 29 '21 at 21:01
The former is a move which passes the initiative on to the opponent.
The latter is a position where that initiative is a burden, and all moves are detrimental to the player with the move.
