2

The tournment director apologied to Firoujza for moving his game on move 60. However, according to Stockfish 12 NNUE d=61the position on the board just before the players moved is evaluated as 0.00, that means a draw. The game indeed terminated with a draw. What the controversy is about?

2
  • Can you give any more info about the analysis? Another site (chessbomb.com/arena/2021-tata-steel-masters/…) shows Stockfish 11 analysis above 1.0 prior to move 61. – BowlOfRed Feb 19 at 21:44
  • Of course I do NOT have Stockfish 12 NNUE , and maybe neither the time to go as far as depth =61. It is simply what was appearing in Houdini 6.02 interface, which has in memory the latest three in - depth analysis other people have done in that position. It too suggested Qd3 for White, but is evaluated 0.00 at depth 61. Or maybe you have confused depth 61 with the 61th move of the game. It seems to me obvious that a depth 61 analysis is more accurate than a depth 24 analysis , although I have to admit that , if truly the position is evaluated as 1.44 at depth 24 it may be difficult to defend. – Stefano Feb 19 at 22:54
3

Computer evaluation is based on perfect play from both sides, which is never the case in human games, and hence is irrelevant here. Given the nature of the position and the time situation, it is crystal clear that Firouzja had the "psychological" advantage, which he could've converted had the game been continued smoothly. Playing with a rook and an unsafe king against the bishop pair under time pressure is a nightmare for every chess player. Maneuvering with the two bishops is much easier. All this, in addition to other factors such as Firouzja's tournament position, makes up the post-game controversy that has arisen.

1

https://chess24.com/en/read/news/tata-steel-chess-apologise-to-firouzja-after-controversy#:~:text=An%20incident%20involving%2017%2Dyear,on%20chess24%20and%20social%20media.

this is the answer to your question

1
  • 8
    This appears to be a link-only answer which may become useless if the link rots. Instead, it would be more useful to future visitors if you summarize the relevant content here and provide the link. – SecretAgentMan Feb 19 at 17:19

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.