17

In the book English opening volume 1 by Mihail Marin at this position

[fen "3nrrk1/bppq2p1/p4p1p/2Pp4/1P1P3N/P1BQ2P1/5PKP/4RR2 w - - 2 21"]

1. Qg6 (1. Ng6)

He suggests Qg6 whereas stockfish suggests Ng6 and evaluation drops from +4.3 to +1.1 after Qg6. I know this is analysed by humans but I am confused about reading rest of the book because I cant trust it now. Any suggestions?

  • What line does Marin give after 1. Qg6 Qf7 (the "rescuing" move according to Stockfish), if he gives one? – Annatar Aug 7 at 10:47
  • Yes it continues as 1.Qg6 Qf7 2.Qf5 +- – Shreyash Talpade Aug 7 at 11:31
  • 12
    Humans are not infallible. Neither is Stockfish (an engine five years from now will probably laugh at many of Stockfish's evaluations. What's weird about that? Don't worry, if all the mistakes you make are only as bad as Mr. Marin's, you won't have a bad chess career – David Aug 7 at 12:04
  • @David Five years from now? Uhhh... Alexa, when was Alpha Zero released? – corsiKa Aug 9 at 3:29
  • @corsiKa good luck trying to install it on your computer – David Aug 9 at 13:52
33

Mihail Marin simply missed that 1.Ng6 is winning, even faster than 1.Qg6. During opening analysis, and even during a game, sometimes when you find a satisfying continuation you forget to follow Lasker's advice and look for an even stronger one.

This is a slight mistake in his analysis, but his evaluation of the variation remains correct (White is winning, even faster than he thought) and I see no reason not to continue studying his book and learning from it.

No chess book is completely void of analysis mistakes. If this is the worst one in the book, then the work is still very trustworthy. However, I encourage you to keep your good habit of checking the author analysis, with your own mind and with engine: First, to prevent falling for a bigger hole in a flawed variation if there is one ; Second, to better understand and remember the positions.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.