1. e4 e5 2. Nf3 Nc6 3. Bc4 Nf6 (The Two Knights Defence is my choice) 4. d3 and I am obliged to play the Giuoco Piano 4... Bc5. I am afraid of the middlegame positions that arise after this opening, because to me it seems that white is in the driver's seat being able to play anywhere on the board f.ex c3-d4 or Be3-fxe3 and then doubling rooks on the f-file or pushing a4-b4 and against all of these plans I feel lost. I can't get counterplay. I've attempted the usual operations: developing my pieces, striking in the center with the move d5 and aiming to equalize the game but it's complicated and I often end up losing the game if not in the short run then will have to endure until a blunder happens in the endgame after many moves of torture. Of course there are many other plans that white might execute but that's even worse for me.
  • 2
    Patience is key. The guioco piano takes a while to get going, so black does best to develop their pieces and prepare the ...d5 break carefully. I personally find it tricky as white if black drops their bishop back from c5 to b6, since this means less things for white to target in black's position. You'd do well to figure out if you prefer to play aggressively or more solid against this opening, as it affects the setups you're trying to go for in the middlegame.
    – Scounged
    Jul 31, 2020 at 1:18

3 Answers 3

[fen ""]
[Event "Ding Liren - Giri"]
[Site "Wenzhou CHN"]
[Date "2017.08.09"]
[EventDate "2017.08.08"]
[Round "2"]
[Result "0-1"]
[White "Ding Liren"]
[Black "Anish Giri"]
[ECO "C50"]
[WhiteElo "2777"]
[BlackElo "2772"]
[PlyCount "90"]

1. e4 e5 2. Nf3 Nc6 3. Bc4 Bc5 4. O-O Nf6 5. d3 O-O 6. h3 d6
7. c3 a6 8. a4 Ba7 9. Re1 h6 10. Nbd2 Be6 11. Bxe6 fxe6
12. Nf1 Nh5 13. Be3 a5 14. Bxa7 Rxa7 15. d4 Qf6 16. Re3 Nf4
17. h4 Qg6 18. g3 Raa8 19. dxe5 Nxe5 20. Nxe5 dxe5 21. f3 Rad8
22. Qc2 Nh5 23. Kh2 Rf6 24. Rd1 Rdf8 25. Rdd3 Qf7 26. Qd1 Rg6
27. Qe1 Qe7 28. Kh3 Rxg3+ 29. Nxg3 Nf4+ 30. Kh2 Qxh4+ 31. Kg1
Rf6 32. Rd8+ Kh7 33. Rd2 Rg6 34. Rg2 h5 35. Rh2 Rxg3+ 36. Kh1
Qg5 37. Qf1 h4 38. Re1 h3 39. Rd1 Qh5 40. Rd7 Qxf3+ 41. Qxf3
Rxf3 42. Rhd2 Kh6 43. Rd8 Kh5 44. Rh8+ Kg4 45. Rd1 Ne2 0-1

I think that the way Anish Giri plays the Italian as Black is very instructive.

It is also funny that White faced all the problems you mentioned having as Black in this game, and it shows how Black avoided the headaches you named.

Some ideas (I would not call them rules...) in the Italian...

  1. I like to go ...a6 and ...Ba7 immediately and only then ...d6. It gets the bishop out of harms way so that we are more flexible in how we react to moves in the center, like d4 (because d4 does not hit the bishop anymore). And we can still retreat it with ...Be7 if that is how we want to parry Bg5 (matter of taste if you want to go for ...h6 and ...g5).
  2. If White goes for the pin with Bg5 before Black has castled kingside, we go ...h6, ...g5 kicking the bishop and we may go for a kingside attack (even after we castle kingside outselves!). A useful maneuver to enable a pawnstorm is ...Nf6-h7 supporting the g5 pawn to play ...h6-h5 (once we are ready).
  3. If White does not go for Bg5 early and plays slowly, a good plan is ...h6, ...Re8, ...Be6 and then ...Rxe6 after the bishops are swapped. The rook may stay on the 6th rank or reatreat back to the 8th.
  4. If White goes for Be3, swapping there is usually okay if we have not played ...h6 yet, as ...h6 weakens squares around our king and we might get crushed after a sacrifice. But you never really have to take and while the rook may look bad on a7, it is not as far from the action as it may seem (see the game I posted).

You will still learn some common mistakes by White, like mistiming d4, leaving f2 vulnerable and others. Another thing to look up is how to deal with unsound sacrifices on f7 or g5 (after ...h6, ...g5 White very often plays Nxg5, but it mostly is not sound).

You also need to look for active play. If White's move seems very slow, or his forces do not look fully coordinated, you might have an opportunity to seize the initiative by striking in the center or on the kingside (mostly). If you look at the game I posted, it is not clear where the initiative of Black came from, but it crushed.

  • Thank you very much! This was a superb reply. Jul 31, 2020 at 23:47
  1. ... Bc5 isn't your only option.

Both MCO-13 and ECO C[55] (1981) list 4. ... Be7 as the main continuation. In the notes, ECO has h6 as an option, or d5, transposing to a line in the Bishop's opening (C24), after 5. exd5 Nxd5.

  • It's not the only option, but it's the best move after 4. d3. Be7 is passive and unnecessary in comparison to Bc5. Jul 31, 2020 at 23:44


Nxe4 has a 100% win score from that position based on players 2200 up to 2400

at 2500 - 2700 BC5 has best results although about 9% worse than whites result

what level is your opponents at ?

Personally I play BC5 and gladly let the Max Lange happen. You might want to memorize that one if you let them play that one as it is complicated.

OTOH The sicilian stops the Giuoco nonsense. So do many other first moves 1... pd3 is good for black too.

  • 6
    I don't understand. You are recommending to answer 1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 Nc6 3.Bc4 Nf6 4.d3 with 4...Nxe4? That "100% win score" must be for White, but I doubt Nxe4 has ever been played above beginner level. Also, after 4.d3 Bc5, the Max Lange is not going to happen.
    – bof
    Jul 31, 2020 at 0:59
  • Look at chesstempo link and see the 2200-2400 players winning 100% with that move as black. See also the 2500-2700 players wining 9% more for white. You can doubt all you want but the data is there from actual games showing you are wrong. True the lange wont happen there after pc3 but it happens a lot and is not to be feared by black. Jul 31, 2020 at 1:56
  • 4
    Did you even read the question? OP is asking about a lline where White played 4.d3 protecting the e4 pawn with a pawn. Nxe4 simply loses a piece.
    – bof
    Jul 31, 2020 at 2:14
  • Wow. A true provable statement and the kiddies downvoted a totally correct answer. WTF?! Aug 3, 2020 at 20:35
  • @bof did you look at chesstempo game database and see the actual results by masters ???? Or are you ASSuming that you are so much better that the move in that database is wrong. Aug 3, 2020 at 20:36

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.