5
[FEN "1k5r/p1p2pq1/2n5/1p1p3n/1P1Pp2Q/P1P1P1P1/1B1K2B1/7R b - - 0 1"]

Today I was playing a game with myself only. This is the condition now it is black to move. What can be the best move in this situation?

12

The knight on h5 is pinned to a rook, and faced with the potential threat of g4. To unpin this knight, Black should play Rh7, so that the knight is free to go to f6 (where it will protect the rook).

[FEN "1k5r/p1p2pq1/2n5/1p1p3n/1P1Pp2Q/P1P1P1P1/1B1K2B1/7R b - - 0 1"]

1...Rh7 2.g4 { This move is just for illustration, and probably not best. } Nf6 

I would argue that Rh7 is the best move in this position. It has been stated in a comment that Stockfish marginally prefers a6 to Rh7 (although it always prefers Rh7 when I try it, at all depths from 3 to 46 - it probably depends on cache state, number of threads, etc.). But from a human point of view, I don’t think a6 makes much sense: all the while the pin exists, White can try to find ways of exploiting it; Black ought to put a stop to this right now. In fact, the main purpose of a6 (from Stockfish’s point of view) seems to be to deal with one possible way of exploiting the pin; but clearly it’s simpler just to remove the pin.

| improve this answer | |
  • You are right I think this will be the best move only in this situation. – Bitthal Maheshwari May 25 at 20:25
  • Why is there so much space between the board and the buttons? – boatcoder May 26 at 14:38
  • @boatcoder: This seems to be a bug. It doesn't always happen: it depends on the size of your browser window and zoom setting. – Stephen May 26 at 15:35
8

In the present position black cannot move the knight, and it appears white is threatening to attack it with g4 but in fact if white plays g4 he won't be able to capture the knight with the pawn without losing the bishop n g2.

...Rh7 is one way to allow the knight to move away to f6 but it is not necessary to play that right away and you could play a move like ...a6 first.

| improve this answer | |
  • See what you are saying is right but white will not take time to change the position of bishop so anyhow black will need to play the move of Rh7. So I think I should go with that move. – Bitthal Maheshwari May 25 at 20:27
  • 2
    Funnily enough, Stockfish (at around depth 33) actually gives 1...a6 as it's first choice, with 1...Rh7 coming behind at a close second. – Inertial Ignorance May 25 at 21:22

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.