I was doing this exercise on lichess, but I don't see why the best move for white is to sacrifice their queen in exchange for a knight (after Nh3+):

 [title "lichess puzzle 61517"]
 [fen "4r1k1/p1b2pp1/1pp2r2/3p2np/1P1P2q1/P3P1P1/2R1NPQP/2R2NK1 b - - 1 28"]

Because white will lose the queen anyway after Nh3+, since otherwise Kh1 is answered with Rxf2 trapping and winning the queen. Just try to work out the tactics by yourself.

As to why white doesn't give up the queen for the rook instead (after Rxf2), it's because in this position the knight+queen are more apt at coordinating and creating threats. For example, to see that even after Qxf2 black can win back the rook if desired, here's a line:

 [title "lichess puzzle 61517"]
 [fen "4r1k1/p1b2pp1/1pp2r2/3p2np/1P1P2q1/P3P1P1/2R1NPQP/2R2NK1 b - - 1 28"]

 1...Nh3+ 2.Kh1 Rxf2 3.Qxf2 Nxf2+ 4.Kg2 Nd3 5.Ra1 Qe4+ 6.Kg1 Ne1 7.Rxe1 Qxc2

One must bear in mind that these are tactics problems, and in this case we know white is lost anyhow after Nh3+ but you should solve them with the mindset that you're playing against an engine, that is, assume the best resistance that exists, and sometimes since the position is lost, the best resistance is to delay the unavoidable exactly similar to how engines would go about such lost positions. Therefore, Qxh3 is presumably the move that yields the best resistance (lowest evaluation value for black's advantage from the engine's pov).

  • Assuming that White has some reason to keep playing after losing the queen (maybe Black is almost out of time?) why is 3.Qxf2 (helping Black get his knight out of the corner) better than say 3.Nc3 Rxg2 4.Kxg2? – bof Mar 10 at 8:35
  • 1
    @bof indeed under those circumstances it might be better for white to use the tempo for a somewhat "developing" move and wait for Rxg2, however, from an objective point of view these lines will all look similarly losing. In fact if white has chances to win by flagging, then I reckon Qxh3 might give the best chances - getting rid of the pesky knight and mustering a tricky defense around the king with the two knights. – user929304 Mar 11 at 14:00

1...Nh3+ 2.Kh1 Rxf2 and White's queen is dead anyway. Sure maybe it takes a rook instead of a knight but it's non-trivial which is worth more in this position.

In either case White's king should be bringing out the white flag.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.