Here is what I've seen described as the main line of the Closed Ruy Lopez up to move 7:

[fen ""]

1. e4 e5 2. Nf3 Nc6 3. Bb5 a6 4. Ba4 Nf6
5. O-O Be7 (5... b5 6. Bb3 Be7 7. Re1 d6) 6. Re1 b5 7. Bb3 d6

I'm interested in Black's fifth move in particular. The top three options, with number of games according to the lichess opening book, are

  • Be7 (43,520). Described in books as going to the Closed Ruy Lopez.
  • b5 (8,126). Described as going to the Arkhangelsk variation.
  • Nxe4 (4,844). Open Ruy Lopez.

Now 5...Be7 is clearly the most popular choice, but after 5... b5 6. Bb3, Black could choose to transpose to the Closed Ruy Lopez with 6... Be7 (shown as a variant in the diagram above). Here are the frequencies after 6. Bb3:

  • Bb7 (3,452). Arkhangelsk variation.
  • Bc5 (2,827). Neo-Arkhangelsk variation.
  • Be7 (1,765). Transposing back to the Closed Ruy Lopez.

My question is why is 5...Be7 overwhelmingly more popular than 5...b5? Assuming Black wants to get into the Closed Ruy Lopez, what would they lose by playing 5...b5? An argument for the latter is that by playing 5...b5, Black doesn't need to worry about the Delayed Exchange variation.

Judging by the book, the transposition is doable and some people do play it, but they are a small minority (less than 5%).

  • 2
    After 5...b5 6.Bb3 Be7, does White systematically goes for 7.Re1, or are there independant options, e.g. 7.d3 or 7.a4? – Evargalo Nov 5 at 16:30
  • 2
    Good question! There are other options, but 7.Re1 is the most popular one. 1324 games vs 232 for d4, 77 for d3, and 67 for a4. – itub Nov 5 at 17:34
up vote 6 down vote accepted

After 5....b5 6.Bb3 Be7, white has the strong option to play 7.d4. Now, 7....exd4 is a mistake, as white obtains a big advantage after 8.e5 Ne4 9.Bd5, which was played in Grischuk-Nepomniachtchi (blitz). Instead, 7....d6 is more stubborn.

In contrast, after 5....Be7, 6.d4 is relatively harmless for black, for example 6....exd4 7.e5 Ne4 8.Re1 Nc5.


      [StartPly "9"]

      [FEN ""]
      1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 Nc6 3.Bb5 a6 4.Ba4 Nf6 5.O-O b5 (5...Be7 6.d4?! exd4 7.e5 Ne4 8.Re1 Nc5) 6.Bb3 Be7 7.d4! exd4? (7...d6) 8.e5 Ne4 9.Bd5


Your Answer

 

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.