8

According to the Wikipedia article of Magic: The Gathering, creator Dr. Richard Garfield has compared the evolution of the game from luck to skill as being similar to that of chess.

According to Dr. Garfield, Magic has and would likely continue decreasing its degree of luck as the game matured. The "Mulligan rule", as well as card design, past vs. present, are good examples of this trend. He feels that this is a universal trend for maturing games. Dr. Garfield explained using chess as an example, that unlike modern chess, in predecessors, players would use dice to determine which chess piece to move.

However, the article on Chess doesn't mention dice in its history. Did predecessors to modern chess indeed use dice? And if so, was it removed as part of a maturation of design to emphasize skill over luck, as Dr. Garfield suggests?

  • 1
    Dice can be used for the starting position of Chess960 (Fischer Random Chess), but I don't know how dice would have been used in early chess. – TheHonestAtheist Jan 31 '18 at 19:02
6

Richard Eales addresses this question in Chess: The History of a Game (p.30):

On one last matter, whether or not the early Indian chess was played with dice, there is simply no evidence on which to base a general conclusion. Al-Biruni saw dice being used in the four-handed game (throw two to move the chariot, three for the horse, and so on), but this is a practice which continually crops up in the history of pre-modern chess, particularly when gambling was involved. The Chatrang-namak described chatrang as a game of pure skill but the dice were not unknown in Islam, and certainly reappeared more frequently in medieval Europe. There is no clue preserved in the structure of the game to betray whether the 'original' chess was played with dice or not.

So it seems that this question is one on which we should remain agnostic.

  • 3
    Not that it helps much, but I recall an line from some medieval drama where someone who has been challenged to a game of chess asks "shall it be with dice, my lord?" I also recall that using or not using dice influenced the attitude of the clergy at a tie whihen playing games of chance was forbidden – Philip Roe Feb 3 '18 at 21:02
3

The strongest circumstantial evidence I know of is from Alfonso's Libro de los jeugos (1283). It has a description of a chess variant played on a 12x12 board with 8 different types of pieces, and describes how to make 8-sided dice as an optional part of the game.

It also mentions a 10x10 variant with 7 different pieces, and how to make/use 7-sided dice.

So playing chess with dice wasn't unthinkable. Since they went to the trouble of describing new dice for the new variants, it makes me suspect that using 6-sided dice for 'normal' chess had to be at least moderately common.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.