# Did Reinfeld make a mistake?

One of the illustrative games featured in Fred Reinfeld's The Complete Chessplayer is a game between A. Muffang - P. Devos, France-Belgium 1948:

``````[FEN ""]

1. d4 d5 2. c4 dxc4 3. Nf3 Nf6 4. e3 e6 5. Bxc4 c5 6. O-O a6 7. a3 Be7 8. Qe2 b5
9. Ba2 Bb7 10. dxc5 Bxc5 11. b4 Ba7 12. Bb2 O-O 13. Nbd2 Ne4? 14. Rfd1 Qe7 15. Rac1 Nxd2
16. Qxd2! Bb6 17. Qc3! f6 18. Nd4! Bxd4 19. Qxd4 Nc6 20. Qc5 Rfe8 21. Rd6 Nd8
22. Qd4! Bc8 23. h4 Kh8 24. Bb1! Rb8 25. Qe4 f5 26. Qe5 Ra8 27. Rc7!! 1-0
``````

The point in question is Reinfeld's commentary on move 16, after `16. Qxd2!`; he says:

A pretty variation is 16 ... N-B3; 17 RxN! BxR; 18 Q-B3 (double attack) threatening mate and therefore winning the Bishop on QB6, with the victorious material advantage of two minor pieces for a Rook.

Translated into algebraic, that is `16... Nc6 17. Rxc6! Bxc6 18. Qc3`:

``````[FEN "rn3rk1/bb2qppp/p3p3/1p6/1P6/P3PN2/BB1nQPPP/2RR2K1 w - - 0 16"]

1. Qxd2! Nc6 2. Rxc6! Bxc6 3. Qc3
``````

But what about `18... Qf6`? That not only parries the mate threat, but if now `19. Qxc6`, then `19... Qxb2`, bishop for bishop, and White cannot even continue with `20. Qxa6?` (taking a vital unprotected pawn), for Black can then take White's other bishop - `20... Qxa2`. In fact, any line of play makes it hard for White to rescue the bishop after `19... Qxb2`. `20. Rd2??`, the only possible move to protect the bishop results in `20... Qa1+!` forcing mate in four. And `20. Bb1`, the only possible move of the bishop to safety results in the loss of his QR pawn - `20... Qxa3`.

``````[FEN "r4rk1/b3qppp/p1b1p3/1p6/1P6/P1Q1PN2/BB3PPP/3R2K1 b - - 1 18"]

1... Qf6 2. Qxc6 Qxb2 3. Bb1 Qxa3 (3. Qxa6? Qxa2) (3. Rd2?? Qa1+! 4. Bb1 Qxb1+ 5. Qc1 Qxc1+ 6. Rd1 Qxd1+ 7. Ne1 Qxe1#)
``````

I don't see any way for White to justify the sacrifice of the Exchange with `17. Rxc6`, since after `18... Qf6` it looks as if Black can hold his own. (Yes, there is `19. Qxf6 gxf6 20. Bxf6` winning a Pawn, but that doesn't make up for the loss of the Exchange. And Black can also double White's pawns and steer toward the endgame with `20... Bxf3 21. gxf3`.)

Am I right in saying that Reinfeld made a mistake, or am I missing something?

-
Phalanx-Scid shows white ahead by after `17. Qc3 f6 18. Ng5 Kh8 19. Nxe6 Rfc8 20. Nc5 Ne5 21. Qc2 a5 22. Bd4 Bb6 (+1.55)` – Tony Ennis Jun 15 '12 at 4:23
After `17. Rxc6`, Phalanx-Scid says: `17. ... Bxc6 18. Qc3 Qf6 19. Qc1 Bxf3 20. Bxf6 Bxd1 21. Bxg7 Rfd8 22. Bd4 Bh5 23. Qd2 e5 (+.73)` so not as good as the straight-forward variation. I'm not sure Reinfeld made a mistake as such since his move still yields an improvement. – Tony Ennis Jun 15 '12 at 4:37
Well, the incontrovertible "mistake" is that Reinfeld said "therefore winning the Bishop on QB6" after `16... Nc6 17. Rxc6! Bxc6 18. Qc3`. – Daniel Jun 19 '12 at 0:13

Yes, it does look like Reinfeld made a mistake, but white should still be doing well after `18... Qf6`.

White should now play `19. Qc1!` hitting the queen and the bishop. Now black's best continuation is to sacrifice the queen with `19... Bxf3 20. Bxf6 Bxd1` leading to this position:

One possible line from here is `21. Bxg7 Kxg7 22. Qxd1 Rad8 23. Qg4+ Kh8` and white has a queen and a pawn for the two rooks, but a strong attack because black's king is so weak.

To summarize, it does appear that Reinfeld made a mistake because after `16... Nc6?` white can simply play `17. Qc3!` and win easily, but even the line he gives should be okay for white.

-
OK, so we both (Reinfeld and I, that is) missed some things. Still a little question - How does `17. Qc3!` win? He can't take the c6 Knight, and to my mind, Black can easily parry the mate threat (for the time being, anyhow) with `17... f6` – Daniel Jun 14 '12 at 15:28
`17... f6` runs into `18. Ng5!!` and white is winning material. Black's pieces are cramped so white will invade along the 7th next move. – Andrew Jun 14 '12 at 15:35
Then what about `18... fxg5`? – Daniel Jun 14 '12 at 15:37
Ah yes - then `19 Bxe6+!` I get it. Then if `19... Kh8` (trying to avoid losing the Exchange), `20. Rd7!` Very fun. Thanks! – Daniel Jun 14 '12 at 15:39
Even better than `19. Bxe6+` is `19. Rd7!!` and black has to resign, but both moves win quite easily for white. – Andrew Jun 14 '12 at 15:44